The Complete Guide to Employee Rewards
Great work deserves to be recognised in a way that feels genuine, meaningful and memorable. Employee rewards paired with meaningful recognition are a great way to show appreciation.
A thoughtful reward can brighten someone’s day, celebrate a personal milestone or recognise a contribution that might otherwise go unnoticed. When it happens regularly, people feel more motivated, engaged and connected to their organisation.
However, spending your budget on generic gifts that nobody wants can do little to inspire or motivate your people. The best rewards are personal, timely and chosen with your team in mind.
In this guide, we’ll look at what drives employee motivation, which types of rewards make the biggest impact and how to build a rewards strategy that delivers value for your people and the business.
What Are Employee Rewards?
Employee rewards are incentives provided by the employer to recognise employees’ professional and personal milestones, separate from their regular salary. They can be tangible, like a gift voucher, or intangible, like an extra day off.
Types of Employee Rewards
Monetary Rewards
Cash bonuses, salary increases, profit sharing and commissions are often the first things people think of. They’re straightforward and can be a great way to recognise big achievements. The downside is that cash is sent and taxed in the same way as the salary, so there are few ways you can make it feel like a moment of celebration.
Non-Monetary Rewards
Not every reward needs to be tied to cash. Extra annual leave, a half-day off on a Friday or a day off on their birthday, public recognition or a personal email detailing what the person’s contributions and their impact mean can be just as meaningful.
Digital Vouchers and Cards
If you still want to give a financial reward but don’t want it to feel generic, gift cards, multi-retailer vouchers and prepaid cards are among the best options. They’re quick to give, easy to personalise and feel like a real treat. Vouchers and prepaid cards can also be tax-efficient in Ireland and the UK in a way cash isn’t, so they stretch your budget further (more on that later).
Experiential Rewards
Offering concert tickets, spa days, weekend getaways, or team-building activities like group meals, cooking classes and escape rooms is a memorable way to reward employees. Experiences encourage social connections and give employees something exciting to look forward to.
Tangible Gifts
Tangible gifts such as hampers, flowers, sweet treats or company merch can be a good option for recognition moments when you want to offer a thoughtful gesture. They also work well for remote and hybrid teams, because a parcel arriving at home is a nice surprise. The main challenges are the logistics involved and the risk that gifts may feel a little generic.
Career Development Opportunities
For many employees, especially high achievers and those in their early career, an investment in their future can be the most meaningful reward. Training courses, certifications, mentoring or coaching can increase motivation and engagement when they align with employee’s interests and career goals without adding to their workload.
How Rewards and Recognition Motivate Employees
Rewards and recognition motivate employees by making them feel seen, valued and part of a bigger workplace culture. When people feel their contributions matter, they’re more likely to take pride in their work, strive for better results and go the extra mile.
Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Motivation
According to psychology, motivation can be either intrinsic (coming from within) or extrinsic (influenced by external factors).
Intrinsic motivation is when someone does something because they genuinely enjoy it or find it personally rewarding. Extrinsic motivation, on the other hand, is driven by external incentives or outcomes. These include tangible rewards, such as bonuses and gift cards, but also recognition, praise or the sense of achievement.
Both types of motivation play an important role in the workplace. Research shows that the right balance between the two can lead to improved job satisfaction, higher productivity and better performance.
Since employee rewards are often linked to extrinsic motivation, let’s take a closer look at how they work from a psychological perspective.
The Psychology Behind Employee Rewards
Leveraging extrinsic motivation may seem straightforward, but in practice, it’s more nuanced. The same reward won’t motivate everyone in the same way, and Victor Vroom’s expectancy theory explains why.
The theory states that what motivates people to perform depends on whether they believe their effort will lead to a result they care about. The theory is centred around three principles:
- Valence: “Do I want this?” - This is how desirable the reward is to the person. A voucher for a restaurant they love has high valence. A generic gift they’d never use has very little.
- Instrumentality: “Will my effort pay off?” - This is how strongly someone believes that their contributions will be recognised or rewarded. If employees see that great work is acknowledged consistently and fairly, they’re more likely to find motivation in their work.
- Expectancy: “Can I do it?” - This is how strongly employees believe their effort will lead to better performance. If a goal feels unrealistic or they lack the right tools and support, even an attractive reward may not be motivating enough.
What This Means for Your Rewards Strategy
Victor Vroom’s theory offers a useful framework for designing more effective rewards and recognition programmes. While it doesn’t explain every aspect of workplace motivation, it shows that one-size-fits-all rewards are unlikely to increase motivation and performance.
So, how can you put the expectancy theory principles into practice?
- Make rewards personal and meaningful – People value different things, so give employees choice and flexibility wherever possible. Offering a range of rewards or letting people choose what suits them best increases the likelihood that the reward will feel genuinely worthwhile.
- Make the link between performance and rewards clear – Be specific about what you’re rewarding and why. This helps employees understand which contributions are valued and reinforces the behaviours you want to encourage.
- Set achievable goals and provide the right support – Rewards are more motivating when employees believe success is within reach. Set realistic expectations and ensure people have the resources, tools and guidance they need to perform well.
How to Reward Employees the Right Way
Allocating budget to rewards that people don’t want, value or connect with is a missed opportunity to engage and motivate your people.
Here’s how you can make sure your employee rewards are personal and meaningful:
1. Ask People What They Value
Rather than making assumptions, ask employees what makes them feel appreciated. You could use a short survey, gather feedback during 1:1s or offer a range of reward options to choose from. It’s also worth revisiting these preferences regularly, as what people value can change over time. The more you understand your employees, the easier it becomes to offer rewards that feel relevant and personal.
2. Set a Clear Budget
Setting a clear budget helps you understand what you can offer, how frequently you can recognise employees and how to distribute rewards fairly across the business. Factor in administration, delivery and any software fees to get a realistic picture of the total investment.
3. Make it timely and specific
Recognition has the greatest impact when it happens close to the achievement or behaviour being celebrated. Waiting until the end of the quarter or an annual review can diminish the significance of the moment. Also, make sure to highlight what the employee did and how their contribution positively impacted the business or team. This makes the reward more personal, memorable and meaningful.
4. Offer choice and flexibility
Your team is made up of different people with different interests and lifestyles. Some employees are in the office, some are remote or spread across different locations. Choosing rewards that allow flexible spending will make sure everyone gets something they want.
5. Keep it simple to administer
Employee rewards can involve a lot of behind-the-scenes admin work – managing budgets and approvals, tracking milestones, arranging distribution and delivery, reporting. It’s worth looking into automating some of these processes, such as delivering digital rewards, scheduling recurring milestones or keeping all programme activity in one central place.
6. Measure and improve
To understand whether your rewards budget is being utilised efficiently, make sure you set up clear reporting on budget spend, tax compliance, predictive costs, reward spend by type and so on. You should also use employee surveys to measure satisfaction and gather ideas. Use what you learn to introduce new reward options or adjust your budget.
Are Employee Rewards Taxable?
It depends on what the reward is and where you’re based. Cash is almost always taxable, but there are generous, tax-efficient routes for non-cash employee rewards in both Ireland and the UK.
The Small Benefit Exemption in Ireland
The Small Benefit Exemption is a tax-relief scheme in Ireland that lets employers give employees up to 5 non-cash rewards, with a total value of up to €1,500, completely tax-free every year.
Cash bonuses are treated as normal pay, so PAYE, PRSI and USC rules apply. But any gift cards, or even prepaid cards, that can’t be redeemed for cash are compliant with the scheme. You still need to report any rewards to Revenue.
See our guide to the Small Benefit Exemption for more details.
UK’s Trivial Benefits
The UK’s equivalent is the trivial benefits exemption, which allows employers to give employees small, occasional gifts without paying income tax.
To qualify, a reward must cost £50 or less, can’t be exchanged for cash, must not form part of the employee’s contract and can’t be given in return for their work or performance. For example, a gift to celebrate a birthday or the festive season can qualify, but a reward for hitting a target or completing a project can’t.
There’s no limit on the number of trivial benefits an employee can receive in a year, as long as each one meets all conditions. You also don’t have to report them to HMRC.
See the full rules on the official gov.uk website.
Disclaimer: This is general information, not tax advice. You should always check with your accountant or tax adviser, and Revenue.ie / gov.uk for the latest rules.
Making Employee Rewards Count
Employee rewards work best when they’re timely and personal. A thoughtful reward, paired with genuine recognition, shows people their work is noticed and valued. Over time, these small but meaningful gestures build engagement, loyalty and a positive workplace culture.
You don’t need to do everything at once. Pick one goal, ask employees what they’d love to receive and start with a few regular moments of recognition, such as employee birthdays and work anniversaries.
To make managing it all easier, try Workbloom. Our platform brings employee rewards, milestone automation, reporting and tax compliance in one place, so you can spend less time on admin and more time celebrating your people.
Test it yourself: Get Free Trial
